Welcome To

Cream Valley Custard

Featured Menu

Ice Cream Cakes

For any event such as birthday, anniversary, or graduation, let us take care of the cake! Please allow 2-3 days in advance for ordering!

We also offer Reese Cup cakes for all of you peanut butter lovers!

Sundaes on Mondays

Each Monday we feature a specialty sundae creation such as this Fried Oreo Sundae FOR THAT MONDAY ONLY!

Give our social media pages a follow to keep an eye out for these special creations!

Weekly Yogurt Flavors

Check in to see what our yogurt flavor of the day is! Flavors change weekly.

Ice Cream Nachos

The perfect date treat! This item is definitely meant for sharing. A heaping bowl of ice cream with your choice of toppings! Use ice cream sandwich wafers as your “chips” to scoop!

Closing Day 2025

Sunday, September 21st will be our last day for the 2025 season. As always, we cannot express our gratitude to all of our WONDERFUL customers. You seriously are the best.

Help satisfy those cravings for Cream Valley during the offseason by placing an order through our “End of Season Stock Up” form. You can order quarts, dixie cups & ice cream sandwiches! All orders must be placed by September 12t!

While our regular season is coming to an end, our holiday season is gearing up! Stay tuned for all of the fun specials coming up!